A recent study published in the scientific journal Transactions of the American Fisheries Society shows 100% safe passage of the endangered American Eel through a novel hydro turbine. The innovative turbine is designed and built by Natel Energy to protect river-dwelling fish species, including eels, while also efficiently generating renewable power. This study demonstrates the highest rate of eel survival ever while passing through a hydro turbine and shows promise that a redesigned approach to hydropower can help protect this critical aquatic species instead of causing harm.
Listed as endangered by the IUCN, American Eels are hugely beneficial to a river’s flourishing ecosystem. Eels help transport water-filtering mussels upstream resulting in improvements to overall water quality and regularly prey on non-native river species like rusty crawfish, stopping their spread.
“Compared to other migratory fish species, freshwater eels face unique risks when passing downstream at hydropower sites,” says lead author and Natel Staff Mechanical Engineer, Sterling Watson. “Their narrow body shape and strong migratory instincts make it a challenge to keep adult eels from entering turbines, and the sharp blades and converging pinch points present in conventional turbine designs can cause them severe injury. That’s why designing for and demonstrating safe passage of eels through operating turbines is essential.”
In the U.S. alone, more than 939 hydropower plants (producing 32GW of power) are within the current population range of the American Eel. This proximity will continue to be an issue for the dwindling species unless new hydropower measures such as fish-safe turbines become standard practice.
"Freshwater eels have been highly affected by the construction of dams and are exceptionally vulnerable to the hazards caused by conventional hydropower turbines. This important study demonstrates a leap forward in safe fish turbine design and demonstrates that a turbine can be designed to protect rather than imperil the species,” said Shannon Ames, Executive Director of the Low Impact Hydropower Institute.
Unparalleled Study Results
This study from Natel was completed in partnership with the scientific research institution Pacific Northwest National Laboratory in the fall of 2021. It comprised 174 American eels divided into treatment and control groups studied at the company’s in-house hydraulic and fish testing facility located in Alameda, CA. The eels measured between 33.9 and 65.5 cm in length, comparable to many silver-stage female American Eels found along the eastern United States and in parts of Nova Scotia.
These tests demonstrated 100% safe fish passage of all 131 eels that passed through Natel’s Restoration Hydro Turbine (RHT). The Kaplan-style propeller turbine is now proven to be thoroughly fish-safe for eels, a first for the hydro industry, raising the bar for what’s possible for hydropower regarding fish protection. Furthermore, this study included the first-ever high-speed video capture of eels passing through a hydro turbine.
The RHT’s runner blades have a very thick leading edge, and sweep forward from the hub to the tip of the blades. These features, combined with the minimal gap between the runner and housing, were designed to minimize the risk of injury to fish, while promoting safe downstream passage.
“This landmark study is a huge win for aquatic wildlife preservation and the entire hydropower industry, showing that it is truly possible to preserve fish species critical to societal and ecological health while helping the planet reach net zero emissions,” said Gia Schneider, co-founder and CEO, Natel Energy.
Hydro Has Been Considerably Detrimental to Eels
Endangered American and critically endangered European eels are born in the Atlantic Ocean and migrate up estuaries and rivers along the coasts of North America and Europe to live and grow before returning to the ocean to spawn. These eels are classified as endangered in part due to multiple factors associated with hydropower development, such as habitat loss and death from hydropower infrastructure including turbine blade strikes, entrapment, rapid pressure changes and shear forces.
Conventional hydropower methods for managing nearby eels typically involve exclusion screens, bypasses or temporary shutdown at night during eel migration season, all costly methods that come with a survival rate as low as 40%. Dams and hydropower prevent the migration of both young and adult eels and contribute to a more significant issue of river fragmentation affecting all migratory river species.
A New Way Forward for Renewable Energy that Finally Protects Aquatic Biodiversity
With the effects of climate change spurring progress and investment in energy renewables, including hydropower, it is critical to pay close attention to any negative impacts on our broader environment or biodiversity.
“It is essential that hydropower development is guided by a scientific understanding of its effects on freshwater resources and wildlife, in addition to an understanding of its low-carbon energy output,” said Abe Schneider, CTO, Natel Energy.
The results of the American eel study are reinforced by the equally positive results of several additional scientific studies conducted with Pacific Northwest National Laboratory and with Kleinschmidt Associates. The parallel studies affirm an average of >99% safe passage of other migratory fish species including rainbow trout and Alewife through Natel’s unique turbine design.
Fish-safe turbines can have an immediate impact on enhancing river connectivity by replacing conventional propeller turbines currently operating in existing waterways. When combined with civil engineering techniques from watershed restoration and man-made whitewater parks, Natel’s fish-safe RHTs can serve as a cornerstone for distributed hydro projects that deliver watershed uplift while also generating reliable, renewable energy.
What Does This Mean?
Demonstrated safe fish passage of the American eel through a new type of hydro turbine gives those involved in the hydropower industry, including non-governmental organizations, regulators, and hydro operators a first-time solution for reliable fish protection. Finally, there is an alternative to costly conventional exclusion screens and plant shutdowns while allowing critical downstream eel migration and in turn, survival.
Gia discusses fish-safe turbine designs as the best available technology for existing hydro plant refurbishments and upgrades and for powering non-powered dams.
This article in French explains how Natel's Restoration Hydro Turbine provides a solution for hydropower plants to coexist with migrating fish.
The company will install up to 90 of its Restoration Hydro Turbines at three non-powered dams
ALAMEDA, Calif. — Sept. 28, 2021 — Natel Energy, a supplier of sustainable hydropower solutions, announced today it will develop, finance and construct three non-powered dam sites along Louisiana’s Red River in partnership with Nelson Energy, a Minneapolis-based firm that has successfully developed and licensed over $250 million of hydroelectric projects in the U.S. With Nelson Energy as an advisory partner, Natel will install between 60 and 90 of its flagship product, the Restoration Hydro Turbine (RHT), to retrofit three existing dams and add 80 MW of renewable power to the grid — enough energy to power 35,960 average US homes each year.